The Values Vacuum: How to Keep Standards High Amid Rapid Growth

In our previous discussion on "Imperfect Action," we explored how embracing the inherent messiness of growth accelerates organizational progress. Yet this raises a critical question: How do we balance taking imperfect action with maintaining the high standards that define our organizational identity? The tension isn't about achieving perfection—it's about ensuring that your core values remain intact as you grow, even while embracing the necessary messiness of scaling.

When Etsy founder Rob Kalin stepped aside as CEO in 2011, the company was at a critical inflection point. Their handmade, artisan-focused marketplace had grown from a small community of crafters to a platform with millions of users. As Chad Dickerson took the helm, Etsy faced significant challenges balancing its growth with its foundational values. A 2012 Wired article highlighted these tensions, noting

Dickerson's efforts to support sellers in growing their businesses without compromising the company's core principles (Wired, 2012). This challenge—where growth outpaces an organization's ability to transmit its cultural DNA—represents one of the most pervasive yet under-addressed threats facing scaling organizations today.

Studies indicate that organizations undergoing rapid growth often face challenges in maintaining their founding values, leading to perceived disconnects between stated principles and daily operations. This gap creates what might be called a "values vacuum"—where carefully crafted standards gradually lose their gravitational pull on daily operations.

When Growth Creates a Vacuum

The values vacuum manifests in several observable patterns as organizations scale:

The Dilution Effect: Each new hire and expansion location naturally dilutes the cultural concentration of your founding team. Without systematic transmission mechanisms, values that once permeated every decision gradually become situational considerations rather than organizational imperatives.

The Efficiency-Values Tension: Growth creates relentless pressure to standardize operations for efficiency. Without deliberate design, these standardization efforts often optimize for consistency and speed while inadvertently sidelining values-aligned decision-making.

The Distance Dilemma: As organizations add management layers and geographic dispersion, the emotional and operational distance between leadership's values declarations and frontline implementation grows exponentially.

Unlike financial metrics that sound immediate alarms when declining, cultural erosion happens gradually—often recognized only after significant damage has occurred. Organizational psychology research suggests that when formal values aren't connected to daily operations, they can become merely aspirational rather than descriptive of actual organizational behavior, eventually risking perception as hypocritical rather than inspirational.

The Standard Approaches (And Why They Fall Short)

Most organizations attempt to address values preservation through three common approaches—each woefully insufficient on its own:

The Delusion of Documentation: Organizations invest heavily in articulating values through mission statements, culture decks, and onboarding materials. While documentation is necessary, it's spectacularly insufficient. As Kip Tindell, former CEO of The Container Store, suggests, embedding values into organizational systems is crucial for influencing behavior effectively.

The Communication Crutch: Others rely on leadership communication to reinforce values—regular all-hands meetings, inspirational emails, and values-focused town halls. However, these efforts often create what organizational psychologists call the "say-do gap"—where leaders' words about values don't align with organizational systems, generating cynicism rather than commitment.

The Training Trap: Many organizations implement values-focused training programs, hoping that classroom experiences will translate to operational reality. Research indicates that traditional values training programs often struggle to produce sustained behavioral change, highlighting the need for integrated approaches.

These approaches share a fundamental flaw: they treat values as a separate component of organizational life rather than the central operating system that should govern everything else. When values exist primarily in statements, speeches, and training sessions—rather than in processes, systems, and structures—they often become disconnected from daily operations amid growth pressures.

Values Infrastructure: The Missing Foundation

The breakthrough comes from recognizing that values preservation isn't about doing more values-related activities—it's about designing systems with your values embedded directly in their architecture. This approach, which might be described as building "values infrastructure," involves integrating core convictions into your organization's operational elements.

This approach rests on a crucial insight: Values aren't maintained through cultural initiatives but through operational design. When your convictions are built into how decisions get made and performance is measured, they naturally strengthen rather than dilute during growth.

Building values infrastructure typically involves attention to several dimensions. Three areas seem particularly important:

1. Decision Architecture & Measurement

This dimension integrates values into both decision processes and performance metrics. Organizations create "values-first filters" that guide choices at every level while developing metrics that track values expression. This creates a closed loop where values guide decisions and outcomes are measured against those same values.

2. Operational Integration

Values must be embedded in how work actually gets done. Design workflows that naturally express core values, with process checkpoints that reinforce key principles. When systems express values by default, maintaining standards becomes effortless. The right process makes values the path of least resistance, not an additional consideration.

3. Cultural Transmission

This dimension focuses on how values pass between generations of team members through storytelling, mentorship, and immersive onboarding. Without these mechanisms, even strong founding values dilute with each new hire. Effective organizations create "cultural apprenticeships" where members absorb values through both teaching and experience.

When these dimensions work together, values aren't preserved through effortful initiatives but through everyday systems. Your organization doesn't just have values—it's built on them.

Practical Steps to Build Your Values Infrastructure

Start building your values infrastructure with these concrete steps:

1. Revisit Core Processes

Assess how your organizational values are currently expressed (or contradicted) in your operations. Rather than attempting comprehensive transformation, focus on redesigning one high-leverage process to better express your values. Choose a process that significantly impacts your mission delivery, map the current workflow and identify where values could be better integrated, then test the new approach with a pilot team before broader implementation.

2. Create Your Values Measurement Framework

Develop specific metrics to track values expression alongside performance by identifying 2-3 measurable indicators for each core value. Establish regular review cycles to assess values metrics and create visible dashboards that give values measurements equal prominence to financial ones.

3. Build Your Cultural Transmission System

Design systematic ways to transfer values knowledge across team expansion through documented founding stories that illustrate values in action, mentorship pairings between values carriers and newer team members, and experiential onboarding that demonstrates values in practice, not just theory.

Values Infrastructure in Action

Organizations across sectors have implemented values infrastructure with remarkable results:

Etsy

Etsy, which we discussed earlier, demonstrates how a for-profit company can scale while strengthening its community-centered values. As they grew from a small artisan marketplace to a public company with over $2.3 billion in annual revenue, they faced immense pressure to compromise their commitment to human-scale commerce and environmental responsibility.

While the specific term "Values-Aligned Growth Framework" isn't used, Etsy's commitment to integrating values into its operations is evident. The company's SEC filings discuss its "Product Development Culture," emphasizing principles and habits that guide teams in aligning product development with Etsy's mission and values (Etsy, 2022).

When Etsy became a Certified B Corporation in 2017, they restructured their board governance to include formal accountability for social and environmental performance alongside financial results. This systematic approach has helped them maintain their distinctive identity while achieving substantial growth since their IPO, demonstrating that values integration enhances rather than hinders market performance.

Bridgespan Group

Bridgespan Group demonstrates how a nonprofit consulting firm maintains its values during global expansion. Founded as an offshoot of Bain & Company, Bridgespan faced the challenge of scaling internationally while preserving their commitment to social impact.

The Bridgespan Group emphasizes aligning operations with social impact goals, incorporating approaches that prioritize mission-driven decision-making. Their work suggests a thoughtful consideration of client engagements based not only on revenue potential but on alignment with their social impact mission (Tierney & Fleishman, 2011).

This approach has allowed Bridgespan to expand their reach while maintaining their focus on transformative social impact (Bridgespan Group, 2019). They demonstrate that values preservation isn't about cultural initiatives separate from operations, but about designing systems where mission advancement is integrated into everyday processes and decision frameworks.

The University of Portland

The University of Portland provides an instructive example of a faith-based institution that has systematically integrated its Catholic values into operational reality while growing enrollment and academic offerings. Unlike many religious institutions that experience "mission drift" during expansion, Portland has found ways to preserve its core identity.

The University of Portland integrates its Catholic, Holy Cross tradition into various institutional processes, with faculty evaluation and resource allocation reportedly reflecting the institution's religious mission. This thoughtful approach to maintaining mission alignment has enabled them to strengthen their distinctive identity while significantly growing their enrollment over the past decade.

What distinguishes these organizations isn't just strong values but the systematic integration of those values into operational reality. They've built infrastructure where their convictions naturally express themselves through everyday systems rather than requiring constant reinforcement through cultural initiatives.

From Values Statements to Values Systems

The organizations that maintain their cultural identity through growth aren't those with the most compelling values statements—they're those with the most integrated values systems. They recognize that preserving what matters most isn't about saying the right things but building the right infrastructure.

The choice isn't between growth and values—it's between intentional design and accidental dilution. By systematically embedding your core convictions into operational architecture, you create organizations where values naturally strengthen rather than weaken through expansion.

The values vacuum isn't inevitable. With deliberate infrastructure design, your 100th or 1,000th team member can embody your founding principles as authentically as your first. The key isn't trying harder to maintain your culture—it's building systems where your values naturally express themselves without extra effort.

Ready to transform your values from aspirational statements to operational reality? Let's explore how values infrastructure might strengthen your organization's identity as you grow.

Contact Us